top of page

Do Judges Matter? You Be the Judge.

Oct 20
6 min read

We spend a great deal of time debating who should be governor, mayor, president, or sheriff. But what about the people who decide what happens when our rights, our families, our property, and sometimes our freedom are placed in the hands of the courts?

In Hinds County, Mississippi, voters have an opportunity this November to answer a question that deserves far more attention than it typically receives: Do judges matter?

The answer may seem obvious. Yet how much do most of us really know about the judges who serve our communities? How many voters can identify the judges on their ballot? How many understand the difference between Circuit Court, Chancery Court, and County Court?

We often hear that elections have consequences. But few elections bring those consequences as close to home as the election of a judge.

A governor may influence policy. A legislator may write the law. But a judge is often the person called upon to interpret and apply that law when the stakes become personal.

When a marriage ends and parents disagree over custody, a judge matters. When a family disputes an inheritance, a judge matters. When a business owner seeks relief from a broken contract, a judge matters. When a person stands accused of a crime and the government must prove its case, a judge matters. And when an ordinary citizen believes the law has failed to protect their rights, the courtroom may be the last place they can turn.

The question is not simply whether judges matter. It is whether we, as voters, give judicial elections the attention their responsibilities deserve.

The power of a courtroom

There is something uniquely powerful about a courtroom. It is one of the few places where an individual citizen can stand before an institution of government and demand that the law be applied fairly.

But the promise of justice depends on more than the words written in a statute or the protections guaranteed by the Constitution. It also depends on the integrity of the process and the judgment of those entrusted to administer it.

Judges make decisions about evidence, procedure, legal rights, and remedies. Their rulings can shape the direction of a case long before a final judgment is entered.

And while judges must follow the law, judicial decision-making still requires interpretation, discretion, patience, and discipline.

Consider two people entering the same courthouse with similar disputes. Each deserves to be heard under the same law, with the same respect for due process and impartiality. That is the standard our courts must strive to uphold.

Justice should not depend on a person's wealth, family name, political connections, or ability to hire the most expensive attorney. Nor should it depend on whether the judge personally likes the individual standing before the bench. The law must be more powerful than the personalities administering it.

Hinds County has a decision to make

On November 3, 2026, Mississippi voters will participate in nonpartisan judicial elections. In Hinds County, the ballot includes contested races such as the Chancery Court District 5, Place 3 contest between Tametrice E. Hodges and Bridgett B. Clayton, and the County Court Subdistrict 2 contest between Bridgette M. Morgan and Yemi "Larry" Kings.

These are not merely contests between individuals seeking public office. They are opportunities for citizens to examine the qualifications, experience, judicial philosophy, and professional records of people seeking the public's trust.

The responsibilities are substantial. Chancery judges handle matters involving families, estates, property, and other equitable disputes. Circuit judges preside over significant civil and criminal matters. County judges exercise jurisdiction over specified civil and criminal proceedings.

Each court serves a different purpose. Yet all are connected by one essential principle: the public must be able to trust that the judicial process is fair. That trust cannot simply be demanded. It must be earned and maintained.

What should voters be asking?

Judicial elections are different from elections for legislative or executive office. A candidate for mayor can promise a new development plan. A candidate for the Legislature can advocate changing a particular law. A judicial candidate, however, is expected to maintain independence and impartiality rather than promise particular outcomes in future cases. Mississippi's Code of Judicial Conduct places restrictions on campaign pledges and promises for precisely that reason.

So how should the public evaluate judicial candidates? We should be asking whether candidates have the legal experience necessary for the court they seek to serve. Whether they understand the importance of due process. Whether their professional histories demonstrate sound judgment, ethical conduct, and respect for the law.

For sitting judges, the public can examine their work, their treatment of litigants, and their administration of courtroom responsibilities using reliable, documented information. For challengers, voters can examine their professional experience, qualifications, and demonstrated understanding of judicial responsibilities.

And for every candidate, there is a fundamental question: Can this individual exercise the authority of the court fairly, even when doing so is unpopular?

That question deserves more attention than campaign signs, political endorsements, or personal popularity.

Justice is not supposed to be a popularity contest

There is an unavoidable tension in electing judges. We ask candidates to campaign for votes, raise money, introduce themselves to the public, and persuade citizens that they deserve office. Then, once elected, we expect them to set aside the pressures of popularity and decide cases independently.

That tension is worth examining. A judge must sometimes make a decision the public dislikes. A judge may have to rule against an influential individual, a powerful institution, or even a position supported by a majority of the community. The obligation is not to satisfy public opinion. It is to apply the law faithfully.

This is why judicial independence matters. But independence should never be confused with a lack of accountability.

Mississippi has established a Commission on Judicial Performance to investigate allegations of judicial misconduct and, when appropriate, recommend disciplinary action to the Mississippi Supreme Court. Accountability and independence are not opposing principles. A healthy judicial system requires both.

The cost of not paying attention

We often measure elections by turnout, campaign spending, endorsements, and political momentum. But perhaps we should also measure our own level of preparation as voters.

How many citizens enter the voting booth knowing the names of the judicial candidates but little about their professional backgrounds? How many select a name because it is familiar? How many skip the judicial races entirely?

These are not accusations against voters. They are questions about whether our civic institutions have done enough to make judicial elections understandable and accessible.

The news media has a responsibility here as well. Judicial races deserve substantive coverage, not simply announcements of candidacy or photographs from campaign events.

Voters need information about the courts, the candidates, and the responsibilities of the offices being contested. They need reporting that distinguishes verifiable facts from political rhetoric. And they need an opportunity to hear candidates explain their approach to judicial administration, fairness, efficiency, and public service without asking them to prejudge cases.

You be the judge

Ultimately, this election is about something larger than any individual candidate. It is about the confidence citizens place in the institutions responsible for resolving disputes and protecting legal rights.

Most of us hope never to face a serious criminal charge, a difficult custody battle, a contested estate, or a lawsuit that threatens our livelihood. But if that day comes, we will want the person presiding over the case to be prepared, impartial, patient, and committed to the law.

We will want a judge who listens before deciding. A judge who understands the limits of judicial authority. A judge who recognizes that behind every case number are real people whose lives may be changed by the court's decisions. And a judge who remembers that the courtroom belongs to the public, not to the person wearing the robe.

So, as Hinds County approaches the November election, perhaps the most important question is not simply who is running. It is whether we understand what we are asking these individuals to do on our behalf.

Do judges matter? Ask the parent fighting for custody of a child. Ask the small-business owner seeking a fair resolution. Ask the family trying to settle an estate. Ask the person whose liberty hangs in the balance. Their answers may tell us more about the importance of judicial elections than any campaign advertisement ever could.

On November 3, the decision belongs to the voters. Do judges matter? You be the judge.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page